• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Tony's Pizza - West Dover: Handmade Pizza & Authentic Italian Subs in Vermont

Tony’s Pizza - West Dover stands out as a local gem on Vermont Route 100, delivering handcrafted pizzas and hearty Italian subs that resonate with genuine flavor and quality. The crust strikes a perfect balance—neither thick nor thin—while robust sauces and fresh ingredients elevate each bite. Longtime patrons praise their generous grinders, especially the chicken parm and meatball parm, which remain satisfying and affordable after decades. Friendly staff and consistent specials complement a menu that also features great calzones, salads, and a solid beer selection. Tony’s offers a warm, authentic experience that captures the essence of classic, well-made Italian-American food in a welcoming setting.

Tony's Pizza - West Dover at a glance

  • Address 194 Vermont Rte 100, West Dover, VT 05356, United States
  • Phone +1 802-464-8669
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant .
  • Popular for Lunch , Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Tony's Pizza - West Dover: Reviews & Ratings

Dezi Johnson
5

Amazing place wonderful staff and absolute phenomenal food, you can tell the pizza is hand made and quality compared to other places half frozen pizzas.

Brendan McFarland
5

I went here over the summer twice now and this is the greatest calzone I’ve ever had . Great food, great service, can’t wait to have again.

Megan Chase
5

Pizza was so yummy and reasonably priced. Staff was very friendly. They'll definitely be seeing more of me!

BSR
5

I’ve been eating pizza and grinders here for decades and it’s still as delicious and affordable as ever. The chicken parm and meatball parm grinders are amazing and really huge and the price can’t be beat. I usually get a large cheese pizza but the meat lovers is also great. They always have really good specials too and a good selection of beers and salads are always available. When I worked at the mountain about 20 years ago we used to get takeaway 5 days a week 464-TONY

Nicholas Rajotte
5

Best Pizza in the area in my opinion! Great sauce, crust isn't too thick or thin and the meat lovers is delicious! Dan, Lisa, and their crew are amazing as well! If you don't want pizza I highly recommend the Italian subso delicious

Roma Zabo
4

Location is great. Place looks clean and staff was very nice. Prices are a bit expansive but it's probably because of the Mt. Snow ski resort. Pizza was good, but nothing special. I'm guessing other pizza shops are even more expansive over here...

Carly Fitzpatrick
5

Just enjoyed a couple of pizzas (meat lovers and white pizza with jalapeño and sausage) from Tony’s and we’re seriously impressed. Nice and thin and crispy and not shy on toppings. So good. This will be our new go to after a day in the slopes.

Bhumi
4

Pizza is the best in town for takeaway pizza! Price is high but similar to other places close by. We order takeaway pizza from Tony’s only and have sit in dinner for pizzas at Flatbread across the road. I really enjoy their chili and corn bread and also Lisa is great! Thank you for the serving the community.

Location

  • Tony's Pizza - West Dover
    Tony's Pizza - West Dover
    194 Vermont Rte 100, West Dover, VT 05356, United States Hotline: +1 802-464-8669

Tony's Pizza - West Dover stands out as a beloved staple in Vermont's vibrant pizza scene. Located conveniently on Vermont Route 100, this local gem offers more than just pizza – it delivers an authentic taste experience that keeps customers coming back. The hallmark of Tony’s lies in its handcrafted approach; every pizza is made fresh, setting it apart from the frozen alternatives you'd find elsewhere.

Among the top dishes, the Cheese Pizza shines with its perfectly balanced crust—not too thick, not too thin—paired with a rich, savory sauce that complements the gooey melted cheese. For those seeking heartier options, the Chicken Parm Sub is a must-try. It’s generously portioned, packed with tender chicken, savory parmesan flavors, and fresh bread that holds everything together without weighing it down. Fans also rave about the Meat Lovers pizza and the calzones, which local food lovers have called the best around, thanks to their robust fillings and masterful preparation.

The staff’s warmth adds another layer of appeal to Tony’s Pizza - West Dover, making every visit not just a meal but an experience. With affordable prices, generous portions, and a menu that includes grinders, salads, and a selection of beers, this spot encapsulates the spirit of casual, family-friendly dining. Whether you’re craving a comforting classic or a rich Italian sub, Tony’s continues to set the standard for quality and flavor in the heart of West Dover.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Kerbside pickup
    • Takeaway
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards